Below are the best articles I could locate today, 27 January 2008, concerning "Stormwater Management and BSD, Better Site Design."
You tell me: Do any of these articles address better site designs, or do any mention the use of infiltration-based Stormwater Management and Better Site Designs?
There is no doubt that natural infiltration of rainfall would be better for Earth and its inhabitants. If the natural eco-systems were allowed to work the way they have always worked, back when:
1) rainwater and precipitation fell from the sky,
2) the water infiltrates/percolates into the soil - right where it fell out of the sky,
3) and replenishes our groundwater and aquifers with pure, clean, filtered water...
... sorta' like the environment has been doing, and working just fine, forever?
Rainwater percolating directly into the soil, at the point where it precipitates - what a concept!
 as opposed to rainwater contacting an impervious surface (conventional paving or non-engineered gravel, or simply dirt that has been compacted by the narrow footprints of pedestrian, vehicular or agricultural traffic)
 becoming stormwater runoff, carrying with it the pollutants it picks up on the surface (usually vehicular fluids or decomposition of brakes/automotive moving parts, but also 'nutrients' from fecal matter and other organic and inorganic chemicals),
 and migrating across the earth surface directly into the nearest surface waterway: into our rivers, lakes and streams (and eventually the oceans),
 INSTEAD: or being 'bio-remediated' by the obsolete storm water runoff diversion, retention, detention, and containment structures still being prescribed today,
 causing the collection of these SWR-borne Nonpoint Source Pollutants into unnaturally high concentration levels,
 chemical concentration levels which overwhelm the natural eco-systems' ability to adequately decompose the pollutants.
Yes, "the cure" being prescribed creates a worse disease! (gee, the natural microbes in the earth can decompose even petroleum derivatives, eliminating any NONPOINT source pollution?)
And the water could instead infiltrate into the subsoil - gee, water can do that?
 Only for the last several billion years,
 before we began covering the earth with impervious structures,
 creating stormwater runoff which picks up pollutants from the earth's surface,
 collecting, concentrating and delivering the polluted runoff water into the nearest surface water, a superhighway to the nearest ocean.
You mean, this pure, filtered water might instead be allowed to replenish our groundwater and the deep aquifers?
 You mean the same, clean water that we drink?
 The same water that the EPA and The Clean Water Act are supposed to be protecting and preserving (as opposed to auctioning off multibillion dollar white elephant BMP and BSD project contracts: to whichever construction companies retain the highest paid lobbyists)?
 ... that water?
Now, you tell me:
(i) Do any of the projects described below appear to be intelligently designed and thoughtful, careful, or effective BMP/best management practices or BSD/better site designs?
well, not really ...
(sounds like the SOP "your tax dollars at play" we have become used to)
But if a truly BETTER site design came along, one that local small urban areas and businesses and homeowners could actually afford to implement, then I ask you ...
|